I’ve heard good things about Mary Kubica and the thrillers she writes. Having read just one other book by her (“It’s Not Her”), I thought it was time to give another one of her books a try. So, “The Good Girl” landed in my reading pile. And while I believe every book is a reading adventure, this one turned out to be a thriller that didn’t leave me feeling thrilled.
I wanted to like this book. Really, I did. And it’s not that I dislike it, it just wasn’t my favorite read. Somewhere around 20% into the story, I started wondering when things were going to get interesting. I’d read another chapter, thinking surely it would start picking up. Nope. Maybe another couple of chapters? Still nope.
The problem? The story just plods along. I never felt that sense of anticipation that made me want to keep turning pages. There were no edge-of-your-seat moments, no shocking revelations that made me stop and think, “Wait… WHAT?” Nothing that made me particularly excited to find out what happened next. Just a story moving from one chapter to the next without much to get worked up about.
Then there’s the whole “Before” and “After” chapter arrangement. The chapters are all titled with some variation of “Mia Before” and “Mia After” – repeated throughout the book, over and over again and again. Initially, I wasn’t even sure what the Before and After were referring to. Before what? After what? And exactly how much time are we talking about here? I eventually figured out the timeline, but I never warmed up to the constant back-and-forth. I can appreciate a story that plays around with timelines when it adds something to the reading experience. But here, I didn’t think it added to the story at all. If anything, I found it distracting and, quite frankly, a little annoying.
The characters didn’t do much to help matters, either. They were just… meh. I didn’t find myself really interested in any of them, and I never developed that connection that made me genuinely care about how a story unfolds. I also kept wondering what the title of this book was referring to, and eventually discovered the reason for “the good girl” – but this element of the story seemed like such a small part, not really worthy of the title.
Even though I wasn’t really into this book, I stuck with it until the end. And I’m glad I did, if for no other reason than to know how the story turned out. Not every book has to be a five-star favorite, after all, right?!
Would I recommend “The Good Girl” to my book-loving friends? Probably not. Is it a book I’ll still be thinking about a week from now? Doubtful.
I’ll probably give Mary Kubica at least one more try. Maybe her other books will be more my cup of tea. But for now, she’s not exactly moving to the top of my to-be-read pile.
My verdict: An adventure I was happy to finish, but not one I’m particularly eager to repeat.
Have you read this book? What did you think of it? Share your thoughts in a comment below and let’s discuss!
Make sure to click on What I’m Reading and follow me on Goodreads for more interesting books to try. And if you like a challenge, make sure to join my Reading Challenges.
The links in this post may contain affiliate links. I’ll receive a small commission (at no expense to you) if you make a purchase after clicking on my link.

