When the Ending Doesn’t Quite Deliver – “The Ending Writes Itself” (Book Review)

I was on a several-month waitlist at the library for “The Ending Writes Itself” by Evelyn Clarke – so when my turn finally came around, I was pretty excited. I didn’t know much about the book, but that title! It sounded like the makings of a fun, clever story, and I was ready for it.

After the first chapter or so, I found myself thinking along the lines of “Knives Out” or “Clue” – two favorites of mine. A cast of characters, a little mystery, some intrigue, and surely a few surprises waiting around the corner. I put on my Sherlock Holmes thinking cap and got to work. And by work, I mean I actually started taking notes about the characters! I rarely take notes when reading fiction, but I was convinced that the little nuances, passing comments, and details about each character were going to be important. I was paying attention. I was connecting dots. I was ready to solve this thing before the author did!

Without giving away anything about the plot, I’ll just say that the story wasn’t quite what I expected. And while I enjoyed the journey, I found myself increasingly puzzled by where it ultimately took me.

The final stretch of the book sort of builds to a point of intrigue. I was feeling confident I had figured out where things were headed. In fact, I had an ending in mind that I thought would tie everything together beautifully. Then came the actual ending. Let’s just say I was underwhelmed.

I couldn’t help thinking the ending I had imagined was considerably more interesting than the one I was given. It left me asking, “Why on earth did all of this happen in the story, only to end this way?” So much seemed to be set in motion, so many little details seemed worthy of attention, and yet the payoff didn’t quite match the buildup.

In a rather ironic twist, I almost feel as though “The Ending Writes Itself” – because apparently, the author didn’t need to write the ending I was hoping for!

Of course, perhaps other readers will see it differently. Maybe you’ll arrive at a completely different interpretation, or perhaps the ending will strike you as exactly right. And maybe that’s part of what Evelyn Clarke intended. Not every story needs to wrap itself up in the way readers expect, and sometimes an ending that leaves us unsettled is meant to make us think.

But here’s what I find most interesting… I’d love to discuss this book with other readers, and not necessarily to dissect the plot or compare theories about the characters. I’d rather sit around a table and pretend we’re the editorial board! I’d ask questions like: Why introduce this particular detail if it doesn’t lead anywhere? Why build up that particular thread if it isn’t going to matter? What was the purpose of taking the story in that direction if this is where we were headed all along? In other words, I want to discuss the author’s storytelling choices as much as the story itself.

I enjoyed the book, and I’m glad I read it. But I was hoping for a little more satisfaction at the finish line. It’s one of those books that leaves me thinking about what could have been rather than simply reflecting on what was.

And now I’m left with one final thought – Hmmm… if only I could have written the ending myself!

Have you read this book? What did you think about it? Leave a comment below and let’s discuss it!

Make sure to click on What I’m Reading and follow me on Goodreads for more interesting books to try. And if you like a challenge, make sure to join my Reading Challenges.

The links in this post may contain affiliate links. I’ll receive a small commission (at no expense to you) if you make a purchase after clicking on my link.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.